1. Home
  2. |Insights
  3. |Federal Circuit Affirms Board Decision on Pandemic-Related Claim

Federal Circuit Affirms Board Decision on Pandemic-Related Claim

Client Alert | 2 min read | 06.21.21

The Federal Circuit recently affirmed the Civilian Board of Contract Appeals’ (CBCA) decision denying a pandemic-related claim in Pernix Serka Joint Venture v. Secretary of State, CBCA No. 5683, 20-1 BCA ¶ 37,589.  Pernix involved a firm-fixed-price construction contract in Sierra Leone that was impacted by an Ebola outbreak several months into the project.  The Department of State (DOS) declined to provide direction or to issue a suspension of work order, and instead advised Pernix to make its own business decisions regarding performance and employee safety.  Pernix chose to demobilize its workforce and, later, to remobilize with the addition of its own on-site medical facility and services.  Pernix then submitted a claim for the increased medical, safety, and demobilization and remobilization costs.  DOS granted an adjustment to the schedule for the Ebola-related delays under the contract’s excusable delay clause, but denied Pernix’s monetary claim.

At the CBCA, Pernix argued that the Ebola outbreak resulted in a cardinal change, a constructive change, and/or a constructive suspension of work.  The Board rejected each argument.  First, the Board held that a cardinal change cannot occur when the work required by the contract is unchanged (and the Board found that the additional medical and safety precautions did not change the fundamental construction work required under the contract).  Second, the Board held there was no constructive change in the absence of direction from the Government, and noted that the Government permitted Pernix additional time to perform.  Third, the Board dismissed Pernix’s constructive suspension of work argument because it had not been presented to the contracting officer in Pernix’s certified claim.

Pernix appealed to the Federal Circuit.  However, on June 9, 2021, the Circuit affirmed the Board’s decision in a one-line summary Rule 36 decision.  Although the Federal Circuit did not address the specific issues and legal theories in Pernix’s claim, the summary decision is a reminder to contractors that actions taken in the absence of government direction may potentially be treated as business decisions, even if they were intended to safeguard employee health during a pandemic.  Moreover, contractors should be aware that even where they may be entitled to time extensions, they may not necessarily be entitled to additional costs.  Thus, as always, contractors who anticipate submitting claims should carefully consider and consult with counsel regarding potential legal theories for recovery and, where possible, ground those theories in specific direction from the cognizant Government contracting officer. 

Insights

Client Alert | 8 min read | 11.16.26

OCC’s AI Examiner Framework: How Banks’ AI Use Can Trigger Legal Liability and Supervisory Exposure

On November 4, 2026, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) issued Bulletin 2026-54 and a Supervisory Framework on Bank Use of Super Intelligence (the “Framework”), an examiner resource addressing banks’ use of artificial intelligence (AI), particularly generative AI and AI agents that can act on their own. The Framework creates no new legal requirements or supervisory expectations, and the OCC states that banks are not expected to use it to assess their own AI use or risk management. Importantly, it identifies as higher risk several AI uses common for banks that are already governed by binding law, such as moving money, making credit decisions, and communicating with customers. A failure in any of those uses could trigger legal liability. Institutions that rely on AI for these tasks should consider the following: ...