Dan J. Hofmeister

Partner

Overview

Dan Hofmeister is a partner in Crowell & Moring’s Health Care Group, where he excels in managed care and prescription benefits management (PBM) litigation and disputes, as well as insurance and indemnity recovery for policyholders and corporations. Dan’s practice includes complex commercial, PBM and coverage litigation, trial work, and arbitrations, including business counseling and work before regulatory and administrative agencies. He serves as the lead lawyer for various managed care and other national and regional companies. He is also the national coordinating and trial counsel for numerous managed care and other companies.

In his over 30 years of practice, Dan has been the lead trial lawyer in scores of high stakes trials, administrative actions, arbitrations, and mediations. Dan is a trusted and skilled advocate, advisor, and negotiator, and one many companies see as a true counselor, as well as a tireless trial lawyer. Dan’s successes and valued advice over the years have set him apart and have galvanized client relationships that have thrived for decades.

By way of recent examples, Dan is a lead coverage trial lawyer and strategic voice for Blue Cross Blue Shield Plans in the Blue Antitrust MDL, its associated opt-out litigation, and as host of other high-profile disputes involving the Blues and other companies. Further, he was the lead trial lawyer in two separate actions in the Virginia state courts where TROs were sought by leading hospital systems from two different courts for a managed care client he has represented for more than three decades. Both TROs were successfully defeated by his client. Dan was the lead trial lawyer for yet another managed care company that received a complete defense verdict from a Louisiana federal court jury concerning a significant payment dispute and purported misrepresentations with respect to a well-known provider group, as well as a complete defense verdict in a North Carolina federal court for another managed care client over a highly complex contract dispute. Dan was also lead trial counsel in a multi-venue dispute in Georgia for a managed care company that resulted in high-value state contracts being awarded to his client. Moreover, Dan argued before the Indiana Supreme Court and secured one of the more significant insurance recovery coverage decisions in favor of managed care companies recovering tens of millions under E&O insurance policies. Dan further had a significant motion to dismiss granted that ended a highly contentious federal court action filed in the Middle District of Florida by a pharmaceutical company challenging his managed care client’s exclusion of their drug from its formularies.

Dan’s work on behalf of his clients is national in scope and involves many of the more challenging issues and disputes a managed care, PBM, policyholder, or other company may indeed face. CEOs, GCs, Heads of Litigation, in-house lawyers, business executives and boards alike seek out his perspective and strategic advice. And while his extensive arbitration and mediation work is largely confidential, his success with some of the most renowned arbitrators and mediators in the country is well known and appreciated, particularly in the managed care, PBM, commercial, and insurance recovery arenas.

Career & Education

    • Loyola University of Chicago Law School, J.D., 1990
    • University of Nebraska-Lincoln, B.A., Journalism, 1987
    • Loyola University of Chicago Law School, J.D., 1990
    • University of Nebraska-Lincoln, B.A., Journalism, 1987
    • Illinois
    • U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Central District of Illinois
    • U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois
    • U.S. District Court for the Western District of Michigan
    • U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan
    • U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Wisconsin
    • U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit
    • U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
    • Illinois
    • U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Central District of Illinois
    • U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois
    • U.S. District Court for the Western District of Michigan
    • U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan
    • U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Wisconsin
    • U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit
    • U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit

Dan 's Insights

Firm News | 5 min read | 08.06.25

Leading Health Care Practices Combine to Provide Comprehensive Counsel to Clients at a Time of Tremendous Change Across the Industry

Chicago – August 06, 2025: Crowell & Moring today announced that a group of 16 highly regarded health care litigation partners is joining the firm, together with their team, and led by accomplished trial attorney Martin J. Bishop. The strategic combination creates one of the largest health care practices in the country and expands the firm’s ability to provide clients across the industry with the full spectrum of litigation, investigations, regulatory, transactional, and recovery capabilities. The team joins from Reed Smith, where Bishop served on the firm’s executive committee....

Representative Matters

  • Obtained dismissal with prejudice in a consolidated action filed in the Central District of California in breach of contract case brought by an out-of-network mental health and substance abuse treatment facility.
  • Successfully defended a putative class action regarding Medicaid insurer’s “opt-out” provision under New York’s consumer protection statute.

Dan 's Insights

Firm News | 5 min read | 08.06.25

Leading Health Care Practices Combine to Provide Comprehensive Counsel to Clients at a Time of Tremendous Change Across the Industry

Chicago – August 06, 2025: Crowell & Moring today announced that a group of 16 highly regarded health care litigation partners is joining the firm, together with their team, and led by accomplished trial attorney Martin J. Bishop. The strategic combination creates one of the largest health care practices in the country and expands the firm’s ability to provide clients across the industry with the full spectrum of litigation, investigations, regulatory, transactional, and recovery capabilities. The team joins from Reed Smith, where Bishop served on the firm’s executive committee....

Recognition

  • Selected through peer review for inclusion in The Best Lawyers in America for Litigation - Insurance, 2023-2025

Dan 's Insights

Firm News | 5 min read | 08.06.25

Leading Health Care Practices Combine to Provide Comprehensive Counsel to Clients at a Time of Tremendous Change Across the Industry

Chicago – August 06, 2025: Crowell & Moring today announced that a group of 16 highly regarded health care litigation partners is joining the firm, together with their team, and led by accomplished trial attorney Martin J. Bishop. The strategic combination creates one of the largest health care practices in the country and expands the firm’s ability to provide clients across the industry with the full spectrum of litigation, investigations, regulatory, transactional, and recovery capabilities. The team joins from Reed Smith, where Bishop served on the firm’s executive committee....

Dan 's Insights

Firm News | 5 min read | 08.06.25

Leading Health Care Practices Combine to Provide Comprehensive Counsel to Clients at a Time of Tremendous Change Across the Industry

Chicago – August 06, 2025: Crowell & Moring today announced that a group of 16 highly regarded health care litigation partners is joining the firm, together with their team, and led by accomplished trial attorney Martin J. Bishop. The strategic combination creates one of the largest health care practices in the country and expands the firm’s ability to provide clients across the industry with the full spectrum of litigation, investigations, regulatory, transactional, and recovery capabilities. The team joins from Reed Smith, where Bishop served on the firm’s executive committee....