1. Home
  2. |Insights
  3. |Solicitation Must Adequately Evaluate Contract Type and Not Have Arbitrary Disqualifications

Solicitation Must Adequately Evaluate Contract Type and Not Have Arbitrary Disqualifications

Client Alert | 1 min read | 09.09.16

In CACI, Inc.-Federal (Aug. 3, 2016), GAO sustained two pre-award challenges to the cost/price evaluation scheme in DISA’s $17.5B ENCORE III IDIQ solicitation. GAO held, first, that the solicitation did not provide an adequate basis to compare the relative cost of competing proposals because, despite anticipating roughly half of the ENCORE III task orders to be cost-reimbursable, the RFP did not require offerors to propose any cost-reimbursable labor rates and, second, that a provision that would eliminate any offeror with a total price more than 50 percent below a “trimmed average total proposed price” of other offerors was “entirely arbitrary in selection and application” because the record did not reflect that such a price difference would pose any inherently high performance risk.

Insights

Client Alert | 2 min read | 02.23.26

NYC’s Mayor Mamdani Joins the Wave of Local Consumer Protection Enforcement

While state attorneys general have traditionally led consumer protection enforcement, local governments are increasingly deploying their own powers to prosecute high-stakes affirmative litigation. The results speak for themselves: Los Angeles and Chicago have secured multi-million-dollar judgments and settlements in consumer deception cases over the past decade....