Recitation of Sufficient Structure May Overcome Means –Plus-Function Presumption
Client Alert | 1 min read | 02.06.08
The Federal Circuit, in TriMed, Incorporated v. Stryker Corporation (No. 07-1327; January 29, 2008), reverses a district court’s judgment of noninfringement based on a finding that the claim at issue contained a means-plus-function limitation.
TriMed alleged that Stryker’s wrist fracture fixation devices infringed its patent whose only independent claim contains the limitation “said holes in said plate providing means for allowing the pin to slide axially therein but preventing compression across the fracture, and stabilizing said near end of the pin against displacement in the plane of the plate.” Stryker moved for summary judgment, alleging, inter alia, that this limitation is a means-plus-function limitation governed by 35 U.S.C. § 112 ¶6 and that this means-plus-function limitation is not present in the accused devices. Stryker asserted that the only structures corresponding to the claimed “means” disclosed in the specification of the patent were “hole[s] plus some other structure.” As the accused devices contain holes and nothing more, they do not infringe.
In reversing the district court’s judgment, the Federal Circuit panel observes that “the use of the word “means” in claim language creates the presumption that § 112 ¶6 applies” but also says that if a claim “recites sufficient structure for performing the described functions in their entirety, the presumption of § 112 ¶6 is overcome.” In concluding that the district court erred in concluding that the language at issue was means-plus-function language, the panel finds that “the claim articulates the structure for performing the claimed functions-the holes” and “[t]he claim language makes clear that the structure for performing these functions is the holes themselves.”
Insights
Client Alert | 3 min read | 11.13.26
Massachusetts Trade Secret Preliminary Injunctions: Prove the Harm, Tailor the Relief
A strong trade secret claim is not a substitute for proof of irreparable harm. In Daikin Applied Americas Inc. v. Russo, No. SJC-13881 (Mass. Oct. 14, 2026), the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court held that likely success on a misappropriation claim does not create a presumption of irreparable harm. The court grounded its ruling in both the Massachusetts Uniform Trade Secrets Act and the traditional equitable principles the statute incorporates. It required a case-specific showing that the requested relief would prevent harm that a final judgment could not adequately remedy.
Client Alert | 1 min read | 11.12.26
SBA Announces Doubling Veteran Contracting Target to 10% for FY 2027, but Questions Remain
Client Alert | 6 min read | 11.12.26
Client Alert | 2 min read | 11.11.26
President Trump Nominates Peter Feldman to Serve as CPSC Chairman and Commissioner
