Infringed Design Patent Requires Combination of Elements To Be Non-Trivial Advance
Client Alert | 1 min read | 08.31.07
In Egyptian Goddess, Inc. and Adi Torkiya v. Swisa, Inc. and Dror Swisa (No. 06-1562; August 29, 2007), the Federal Circuit affirms, with a dissenting opinion, a district court’s grant of a summary judgment motion of noninfringement in an action involving a fingernail buffer design patent. No reasonable jury could conclude, says the Federal Circuit panel majority, that the point of novelty asserted by the patentee is a non-trivial advance over the prior art.
In the two-prong test for design patent infringement, the second prong places the burden on the patentee to identify the points of novelty of the patented design. The accused design must incorporate the points of novelty in order for the patent to be infringed. The patentee may assert that the point of novelty isn’t a single element, but a combination of elements which already exist in the prior art, the combination of those elements being the point of novelty.
The Federal Circuit two-member majority affirms the lower court’s decision that the combination of four prior art elements asserted to be the point of novelty does not constitute a non-trivial advance over the prior art. The dissenting opinion asserts that the majority hereby creates a new rule, namely the “non-trivial advance” rule, which only applies to patents asserting a combination of elements as a point of novelty.
Insights
Client Alert | 4 min read | 09.12.25
SBA’s OHA Further Defines Extraordinary Action in SDVOSB Appeal
On September 4, 2025, the Small Business Administration’s (SBA) Office of Hearings and Appeals (OHA) granted an appeal challenging SBA’s determination that a service-disabled veteran did not control an entity applying for Service-Disabled Veteran-Owned Small Business (SDVOSB) status based on a minority owner’s ability to block certain actions in the matter of VSBC Appeal of: Blue Skye Foods, LLC, SBA No. VSBC-442-A.
Client Alert | 6 min read | 09.11.25
U.S. Department of Commerce Partially Relaxes Export Controls on Syria
Client Alert | 9 min read | 09.11.25
Client Alert | 1 min read | 09.10.25