High Level Of Materiality And Intent Required For Unenforceability Due To Withheld Information
Client Alert | 1 min read | 10.05.06
In Kemin Foods, L.C. v. Pigmentos Vegetales Del Centro S.A. DE C.V. , (Nos. 05-1479, -1480 and 06-1002; September 25, 2006), the Federal Circuit affirms the district court's denial of Pigmentos request for holding the patent-in-suit unenforceable for failing to disclose a journal article to the patent examiner. The patent-in-suit relates extracting purified lutein from plants for use in dietary health supplements. The withheld article, published in the journal Poultry Science, discloses methods for obtaining a purified lutein that is not suitable for human consumption. This article was used as the basis for experimentation by Kemin's president, who was not an inventor and was found to be only tangentially involved in the prosecution of the application for the patent-in-suit.
Despite a jury finding that this article was material to the patentability of the patent-in-suit and that it was withheld with an intent to deceive, the district court concluded that the levels of materiality and intent were not high enough to hold the patent unenforceable. The Federal Circuit, relying upon the testimony of Kemin's president that he did not believe the article to be material and his tangential involvement in the prosecution of the application, finds no clear error in the district court's findings of the level of materiality and intent.
Insights
Client Alert | 8 min read | 09.09.25
On September 5, 2025, the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) withdrew its appeals of decisions issued by Texas and Florida federal district courts, which enjoined the FTC from enforcing a nationwide rule banning almost all noncompete employment agreements. Companies, however, should not read this decision to mean that their noncompete agreements will no longer be subjected to antitrust scrutiny by federal enforcers. In a statement joined by Commissioner Melissa Holyoak, Chairman Andrew Ferguson stressed that the FTC “will continue to enforce the antitrust laws aggressively against noncompete agreements” and warned that “firms in industries plagued by thickets of noncompete agreements will receive [in the coming days] warning letters from me, urging them to consider abandoning those agreements as the Commission prepares investigations and enforcement actions.”
Client Alert | 7 min read | 09.08.25
California’s Climate Disclosure Laws Continue to Roll Forward
Client Alert | 3 min read | 09.08.25
RADV Audits: Implications and Recommendations for Medicare Advantage Organizations
Client Alert | 3 min read | 09.04.25