General Statements Regarding Known Structures are Insufficient to Support Means-Plus-Function Claims
Client Alert | 1 min read | 06.20.07
In Biomedino, LLC v. Waters Technologies Corp. (No. 2006-1350, June 18, 2007) the Federal Circuit affirms a district court’s invalidity determination based on the finding that the recited “control means for automatically operating valving” fails to satisfy the requirements of 35 U.S.C. § 112, ¶ 6. The parties agreed on the applicable claim function, as well as the fact that the only references in the specification to the “control means” are a box labeled “Control” in one of the figures, and a statement that the valving “may be controlled automatically by known differential pressure, valving and control equipment.” Thus, the issue before the Federal Circuit was whether this limited structural disclosure is sufficient to satisfy the requirements of 35 U.S.C. § 112, ¶ 6.
Based on the underlying principle that a patentee need not disclose details of structures well known in the art, the patentee argued that the inquiry should be whether one skilled in the art would have identified the relevant structure from the provided description. The Federal Circuit panel disagrees, however, and concludes that “the relevant inquiry is whether one skilled in the art would understand the specification itself to disclose a structure, not simply whether that person would be capable of implementing a [known] structure.” As such, the court finds the bare statement relating to known techniques for “automatically operating valving” is insufficient to satisfy the requirements of § 112, ¶ 6.
Insights
Client Alert | 4 min read | 11.19.26
Since the choppy rollout of the U.S. Small Business Administration’s (SBA) Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) in the early days of the pandemic, the long wake of enforcement actions has followed in waves. First to fall were the bad actors, relying on falsified paperwork for employees and entities and using the loan proceeds to purchase Lamborghinis. Next were those loan recipients who fell victim to the complexities and changes in the loan eligibility requirements, many of which are grounded in the SBA’s existing complex regulations regarding affiliation. While government contractor PPP loan recipients have largely stayed out of the spotlight in reported settlements and False Claims Act (FCA) litigation to date, a recent enforcement action previews that a new wave is coming with government contractors as the target.
Client Alert | 1 min read | 11.19.26
GSA and DHS Launch E-Verify Enforcement Initiative Targeting Contractors
Client Alert | 3 min read | 11.17.26
CMS Final OPPS Rule Will Reduce Reimbursement for 340B Drugs
Client Alert | 9 min read | 11.17.26
Priorities and Prospects for AI Legislation in the New Congress
