1. Home
  2. |Insights
  3. |CAFO Rule - Environmental Groups Identify Their Legal Claims

CAFO Rule - Environmental Groups Identify Their Legal Claims

Client Alert | 1 min read | 06.01.03

The parties litigating EPA's revised CAFO regulations filed papers in May identifying the claims that they intend to assert. Four environmental groups (so far) have challenged the CAFO rule in court. These related cases, in addition to suits by four industry associations, have been consolidated in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. Although most of the parties submitted only generalized statements of their claims, the list submitted by the Sierra Club is detailed enough to provide some insight into the regulatory changes the group wants to require.

Sierra Club's filing indicates that it will challenge:

  • EPA's recognition of any CAFO land application area runoff as exempt "agricultural storm water discharge";
  • EPA's failure to require sufficient restrictions on land application of CAFO waste in watersheds where water quality is impaired;
  • EPA's failure to require agency approval of, and public review and comment on, each CAFO's nutrient management plan;
  • EPA's decision to allow the use of "general permits" that do not involve public review and comment on each CAFO's permit application;
  • EPA's elimination of the "co-permitting" and "integrator liability" provisions that were in included in the proposed CAFO rule; and
  • EPA's failure to adequately protect groundwater, including requirements for groundwater monitoring.

Sierra Club's list also threatens to challenge EPA's identification of the "best available technology economically achievable" and the agency's purported failure to limit metals, pathogens, antibiotics, and other pollutants in CAFO waste.

Insights

Client Alert | 6 min read | 11.21.26

New Executive Order: “Protecting the Executive’s Privileges and Enhancing Efficiencies in Federal Contracting”

On November 20, President Trump issued “Protecting the Executive’s Privileges and Enhancing Efficiencies in Federal Contracting,” directing all federal contractors to “immediately” notify the White House and contracting agencies of pending or future congressional requests concerning their communications or work with the executive branch. According to the executive order (EO), contractors must also follow instructions to withhold communications from Congress that the White House or contracting agency determines are protected by executive privilege. The order also reaches subcontractors working on federal contracts. Agencies are directed to coordinate appropriate responses and privilege assertions, including by making primes responsible for ensuring subcontractor compliance....