Acid Claims Not Infringed By Partly Neutralized Acid
Client Alert | 1 min read | 03.30.06
In Kao Corp., et al. v. Unilever United States, Inc., et al. (No. 05-1036, -1049; March 21, 2006), a Federal Circuit panel affirms a trial court's holding that Kao's patent is valid and enforceable but not infringed. The trial court interpreted Kao's claim to cover the acid forms of a copolymer and to exclude the salt forms of the copolymer. This claim construction was based, in part, on Kao's filing of another application directed to the salt form. The trial court took this filing as evidence that the patent in suit did not cover salt forms of the copolymer.
Unilever's accused infringing product included the claimed copolymer, but it was partially neutralized into the salt form. Unilever argued that it uses the salt form of the copolymer, and the Federal Circuit panel determines that Kao failed to rebut this assertion, other than offering an unsupported conclusion that Unilever uses a slightly neutralized acid and not a salt. Addressing Kao's argument that even if Unilever uses a salt it still infringes the claims, the panel distinguishes cases where an acid claim was infringed by a salt because in those cases the claims included the salt. Judge Newman dissents, pointing out that neutralizing 14.5% of the acid groups in the copolymer does not yield a salt and also that the record supports Kao's argument that Unilever uses a slightly neutralized acid.
Insights
Client Alert | 4 min read | 11.19.26
Since the choppy rollout of the U.S. Small Business Administration’s (SBA) Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) in the early days of the pandemic, the long wake of enforcement actions has followed in waves. First to fall were the bad actors, relying on falsified paperwork for employees and entities and using the loan proceeds to purchase Lamborghinis. Next were those loan recipients who fell victim to the complexities and changes in the loan eligibility requirements, many of which are grounded in the SBA’s existing complex regulations regarding affiliation. While government contractor PPP loan recipients have largely stayed out of the spotlight in reported settlements and False Claims Act (FCA) litigation to date, a recent enforcement action previews that a new wave is coming with government contractors as the target.
Client Alert | 1 min read | 11.19.26
GSA and DHS Launch E-Verify Enforcement Initiative Targeting Contractors
Client Alert | 3 min read | 11.17.26
CMS Final OPPS Rule Will Reduce Reimbursement for 340B Drugs
Client Alert | 9 min read | 11.17.26
Priorities and Prospects for AI Legislation in the New Congress
