1. Home
  2. |Insights
  3. |Supreme Court Denies UT’s Bid for Med Students FICA Refund

Supreme Court Denies UT’s Bid for Med Students FICA Refund

Client Alert | 1 min read | 05.05.15

The Supreme Court denied without comment the University of Texas' petition to recoup $11 million in Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) taxes paid with respect to medical residents, letting stand a Fifth Circuit decision denying the refunds because the residents were not "students."

UT's argument was based on Texas's "§ 218 agreement" with the Social Security Agency (SSA), pursuant to which Texas opted into the Social Security system for its employees. The § 218 agreement excludes services performed by students, and therefore such services are exempt from FICA tax. Applying a contractual approach to Texas's § 218 agreement, the Fifth Circuit noted that at the time Texas entered into the agreement, the SSA clearly stated its position that medical residents did not fall within the meaning of the term "student" for purposes of the student exclusion. There was no evidence presented that Texas had a different understanding.

In its petition to the Supreme Court, UT argued that the Fifth's opinion conflicted with a similar Eighth Circuit case, Minnesota v. Apfel, which potentially caused a difference in law between the Eighth Circuit and the rest of the country. After Apfel, however, the IRS adopted regulations stating that a school employee who works 40 or more hours per week is not exempt from FICA taxes. Those regulations are applicable for services performed on or after April 1, 2005.

Crowell & Moring's Education Group will continue to monitor cases and legislation important to post-secondary education institutions, ensuring awareness of any changes.

Contacts

Insights

Client Alert | 6 min read | 11.21.26

New Executive Order: “Protecting the Executive’s Privileges and Enhancing Efficiencies in Federal Contracting”

On November 20, President Trump issued “Protecting the Executive’s Privileges and Enhancing Efficiencies in Federal Contracting,” directing all federal contractors to “immediately” notify the White House and contracting agencies of pending or future congressional requests concerning their communications or work with the executive branch. According to the executive order (EO), contractors must also follow instructions to withhold communications from Congress that the White House or contracting agency determines are protected by executive privilege. The order also reaches subcontractors working on federal contracts. Agencies are directed to coordinate appropriate responses and privilege assertions, including by making primes responsible for ensuring subcontractor compliance....