Full Claim Scope Must Be Enabled To Avoid Invalidity
Client Alert | 1 min read | 02.05.08
In Sitrick v. Dreamworks, LLC, (No. 07-1174, February 1, 2008), a Federal Circuit panel affirms a district court’s judgment of invalidity for lack of enablement. The claims at issue are directed to integrating user generated audio or visual content into a pre-existing video game or movie by “selectively substitut[ing] user image data for predefined character image data so as to provide an audiovisual presentation that includes the [user provided] image integrated therein.” The accused product allows users to combine their own voice with pre-existing video images stored on a DVD.
Citing to Auto. Techs. Int’l, Inc. v. BMW of N. Am., Inc., 501 F.3d 1274 (Fed. Cir. 2007), the panel reasons that, because the asserted claims are broad enough to cover both movies and video games, the patent disclosure must enable both embodiments. According to the panel opinion, a “patentee who chooses broad claim language must make sure the broad claims are fully enabled.” The asserted claims are not deemed to be enabled in the context of movies because, unlike video games, movies do not rely on discrete address and control signals. In support of its conclusion, the Federal Circuit panel also notes the undisputed evidence showing that it is difficult, if not impossible, to isolate any one voice from the rest of the sounds in movie soundtracks.
Insights
Client Alert | 8 min read | 11.16.26
OCC’s AI Examiner Framework: How Banks’ AI Use Can Trigger Legal Liability and Supervisory Exposure
On November 4, 2026, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) issued Bulletin 2026-54 and a Supervisory Framework on Bank Use of Super Intelligence (the “Framework”), an examiner resource addressing banks’ use of artificial intelligence (AI), particularly generative AI and AI agents that can act on their own. The Framework creates no new legal requirements or supervisory expectations, and the OCC states that banks are not expected to use it to assess their own AI use or risk management. Importantly, it identifies as higher risk several AI uses common for banks that are already governed by binding law, such as moving money, making credit decisions, and communicating with customers. A failure in any of those uses could trigger legal liability. Institutions that rely on AI for these tasks should consider the following:
Client Alert | 3 min read | 11.13.26
Massachusetts Trade Secret Preliminary Injunctions: Prove the Harm, Tailor the Relief
Client Alert | 1 min read | 11.12.26
SBA Announces Doubling Veteran Contracting Target to 10% for FY 2027, but Questions Remain
Client Alert | 6 min read | 11.12.26
